Help me figure this one out.
Moderator: hbartel
Help me figure this one out.
I've been making up a batch of SSC and Open B birds for the upcoming season. Essentially they are nothing but J.A.B.A.C.'s (just another Battle Axe clone). It has been my belief that the 495 sq in wing on the standard Battle Axe should be a little bit bigger, something closer to about 550-575 sq in or so. Thus, I cut a batch of wings with a 1 in chord increase, made new pylons for them and mounted them on the rails. They turn a little tighter, as I had hoped, and they don't seem to be any slower. The c.g. is in an acceptable position and they are stable. BUT, they have a strange and unacceptable characteristic that I can't account for. When flying along, and without any control input, they will occasionally "bunt" down slightly and start a descent of about 20 deg or so. They recover with normal control input. Because of this, I can't take my eyes off of them to look for streamers. That makes them not very usable for combat. The only thing that I can think of is that because the wing has a larger chord and the trailing edge of the wing is a little closer to the stab, and therefor a little more short coupled, that somehow there is a "blanking" effect taking place from the down wash of the wing interfering with the stab. I can't think of any cure except to increase the size of the stab in hope of getting it out of the down wash. Anybody else got any ideas?
Gary James
Weatherford, TX
RCCA #908
[img]http://www.rccagallery.com/albums/garyjames/Trample_the_Weak.jpeg[/img]
Weatherford, TX
RCCA #908
[img]http://www.rccagallery.com/albums/garyjames/Trample_the_Weak.jpeg[/img]
Re: Help me figure this one out.
More info: I went out and flew it some more today and it diverges equally upward and downward, not just downward. I'm going to try stiffening the stab with some more skewers because I found it to be a little flexible near the leading edge, and if that doesn't work, I'm going to try a larger stab and perhaps change the incidence angle (it's set to zero)
Gary James
Weatherford, TX
RCCA #908
[img]http://www.rccagallery.com/albums/garyjames/Trample_the_Weak.jpeg[/img]
Weatherford, TX
RCCA #908
[img]http://www.rccagallery.com/albums/garyjames/Trample_the_Weak.jpeg[/img]
Re: Help me figure this one out.
Gary
Try putting a little weight on the nose to change CG and see what that does.
Try putting a little weight on the nose to change CG and see what that does.
Re: Help me figure this one out.
Gary
Try putting a little weight on the nose to change CG and see what that does.
Try putting a little weight on the nose to change CG and see what that does.
Re: Help me figure this one out.
After you trim it for straight and level flight is the elevator neutral or up or down a bit? If it is up or down you may need to adjust both ailerons up or down to get the elevator to neutral. Sometimes the ailerons and elevator are fighting to control the pitch and can cause similar signs. Being tail heavy and or a combination of both could cause it also.
Mike Fredricks
RCCA# 109
Home of Hattrick Enterprises
www.hattrickrc.com
RCCA# 109
Home of Hattrick Enterprises
www.hattrickrc.com
Re: Help me figure this one out.
I slid the wing/pylon back 1" on the rails to make the airplane more nose heavy, and got the same results. I'll take a look at the stab/aileron trim when I get back from this 5-day trip, but I seem to recall that it's pretty darn close to neutral. thanks for the ideas so far.
Gary James
Weatherford, TX
RCCA #908
[img]http://www.rccagallery.com/albums/garyjames/Trample_the_Weak.jpeg[/img]
Weatherford, TX
RCCA #908
[img]http://www.rccagallery.com/albums/garyjames/Trample_the_Weak.jpeg[/img]
- Dane McGee
- Posts: 885
- Joined: Fri Feb 21, 2003 1:57 pm
- Location: Greenville, Texas
Re: Help me figure this one out.
Is the trailing edge of the ailerons square or tapered? I've had squirrly results from tapered stock.
I only use 3/16 flat stock.
Have you tried a subfin?
I only use 3/16 flat stock.
Have you tried a subfin?
Dane "Mad Max" McGee
Greenville, Texas
RCCA Vice President 684
Greenville, Texas
RCCA Vice President 684
- Dr. Kamakaze
- Posts: 169
- Joined: Tue Apr 24, 2007 8:51 pm
- Location: USA
Re: Help me figure this one out.
I echo what Hattrick says...adjusting the reflex on the ailerons does help like he said. Usually only a couple of turns of the clevis on both ailerons is all it takes. I had similar problems with my SSC planes being very pitch sensitive. I ended up lengthening the fuselages on all of them and they are now much more stable for me. Of course making sure the CG is right is the first step. Good luck!
Andy "Dr. Kamakaze" Runte
-TEAM KAMAKAZE-
RCCA #876, North Central District Rep
AMA #273119
-TEAM KAMAKAZE-
RCCA #876, North Central District Rep
AMA #273119
Re: Help me figure this one out.
Another thing to consider is the possibility of having an elevator servo that is double centering and drifting erratically. I have encountered such problems with several older Hitec HS-81 servos, even when they were new. At the time it was hard to diagnose as the amount of movement was very small. Sometimes they would later self correct on their own, but if I had trimmed for one position, it would suddenly be wrong. On the ailerons it is harder to tell what is going on, but on the elevator it can be much more obvious you have a problem. It might not be it, but just wanted to throw that out there.
Also, for what it is worth, I have played with BA clones with up to 12" root chord and 18% thickness ( good for beginners and close fields ) and never encountered shielding of the conventional elevator setup...although that can certainly make things interesting when it does happen. My airfoil of choice may have also had some something to do with my experiences. Let us know what you find out.
Also, for what it is worth, I have played with BA clones with up to 12" root chord and 18% thickness ( good for beginners and close fields ) and never encountered shielding of the conventional elevator setup...although that can certainly make things interesting when it does happen. My airfoil of choice may have also had some something to do with my experiences. Let us know what you find out.
Chris Gunter
East TN
RCCA #954
East TN
RCCA #954
Re: Help me figure this one out.
If you use two channels for ailerons (which I do) you can use flap trim to adjust reflex in flight if you set the plane up as having "flaperons".
I leave the elevator neutral and trim out using the flap trim. This seems to avoid the issues you are describing.
I leave the elevator neutral and trim out using the flap trim. This seems to avoid the issues you are describing.
Keith Jones
AMA CD #7601
Radio Control Club of Detroit
and proud member of the OGC
AMA CD #7601
Radio Control Club of Detroit
and proud member of the OGC
Re: Help me figure this one out.
That requires two servos for ailerons. Right Keith???
Bob (Longhaul) Loescher
rcca# 621 RC Combat Geezer
Bring those planes in closer where I can see them.
[url=http://www.rccombat.net/gallery/main.php?g2_view=core.DownloadItem&g2_itemId=11380][img]http://www.rccombat.net/gallery/main.php?g2_view=core.DownloadItem&g2_itemId=11381[/img][/url]
rcca# 621 RC Combat Geezer
Bring those planes in closer where I can see them.
[url=http://www.rccombat.net/gallery/main.php?g2_view=core.DownloadItem&g2_itemId=11380][img]http://www.rccombat.net/gallery/main.php?g2_view=core.DownloadItem&g2_itemId=11381[/img][/url]
Re: Help me figure this one out.
That's right Bobboiler wrote:That requires two servos for ailerons. Right Keith???
I got too much flutter with single servo set-ups, especially in Open B.
Keith Jones
AMA CD #7601
Radio Control Club of Detroit
and proud member of the OGC
AMA CD #7601
Radio Control Club of Detroit
and proud member of the OGC
Re: Help me figure this one out.
I also had issues with servos not acting properly. After 2 new servos doing the same thing, I tried a different receiver. Same thing. I figured the transmitter saw too much rain. Different transmitter and everything worked just fine.Blue Note wrote:Another thing to consider is the possibility of having an elevator servo that is double centering and drifting erratically. I have encountered such problems with several older Hitec HS-81 servos, even when they were new. At the time it was hard to diagnose as the amount of movement was very small. Sometimes they would later self correct on their own, but if I had trimmed for one position, it would suddenly be wrong. On the ailerons it is harder to tell what is going on, but on the elevator it can be much more obvious you have a problem. It might not be it, but just wanted to throw that out there.
I did have the same thing happen with the Hobby King Oranage Futaba 2.4 clones. Failsafe disabled like the instructions said and it did the same thing. Once, you gave it input, it went to where you wanted it to go. But try to fly straight, and it wouldn't hold center.
William "Dominator" Drumm III
RCCA Secretary/Treasurer #713
RCCA Secretary/Treasurer #713
Re: Help me figure this one out.
Well, the problem is solved. And the award for best guess goes to BlueNote. Chris was right, it was a bad servo. I went out to the garage last night and started testing the elevator servo. I could hear it "chattering" and noticed that it wasn't centering accurately. It was very "soft" around neutral and would change "neutral" position without any radio input.
I changed out the elevator servo and went out to do some test flying today. The plane flies great now. It's stable, it turns a little tighter, appears to be just as fast and is simpler to build with a lower parts count.
So, THANKS! to all of you guys who gave me suggestions on what to look for. Now.... check 6!
I changed out the elevator servo and went out to do some test flying today. The plane flies great now. It's stable, it turns a little tighter, appears to be just as fast and is simpler to build with a lower parts count.
So, THANKS! to all of you guys who gave me suggestions on what to look for. Now.... check 6!
Gary James
Weatherford, TX
RCCA #908
[img]http://www.rccagallery.com/albums/garyjames/Trample_the_Weak.jpeg[/img]
Weatherford, TX
RCCA #908
[img]http://www.rccagallery.com/albums/garyjames/Trample_the_Weak.jpeg[/img]